It’s all about ME!

by Tess on July 2, 2009 · 20 comments

in Blogging, Community and friends

salesman

My recent post on whether we’re too polite drew a great debate – thank you to all who contributed. I want to pick out something regular commenter kigen had to say about blogs:

The worst thing about them is self-analysis, self-promotion and extensions from that, the supposed self-help for others. It makes sense of course, the self is free for the writer to plunder, constant daily content readily available, free of copyright. it is supposed that all anybody wants to read about is SELF-HELP, and so to draw in the reader there is all this advice for YOU to care about YOU, to advance YOU, on and on. Isn’t there some other topic bloggers would like to talk about!! And even when they address something outside themselves, they do very little research on the topic, it’s about their trip to the event, or their feelings about what someone wrote, or what THEY didn’t like about this, that, and another. How about some good journalism, real reporting, with no reference whatsoever to the author’s personal involvement in that topic? The age level of blogging is teeny-oriented it seems by its very nature. Can that be changed or not?

Actually it’s the personalisation of experiences I enjoy reading about. If I like someone’s blog and their style, then I will gladly read their opinions. I find their feelings about something more interesting than an unbiased critique. I value the bias, and can always collect alternative views elsewhere. But I appreciate not everyone thinks like me.

Specialist blogs

One thing to consider is a blog’s niche. If I’ve subscribed to a blog which I hope will help me develop, or help me make money, then I expect that blog to focus on ways of helping me, not someone else, or the world. There are times when we have to give ourselves permission to be selfish.

There are so many blogging niches: technology, social media, politics, art, writing, business, religion, ecology, fashion, entertainment and many more. In this mix are some excellent writers and some truly terrible ones. There are certainly many writers whose focus is their subject matter, not themselves.

Personal blogs

But perhaps kigen’s reference is to those of us who write personal blogs. We don’t have anything to sell, and often only a loose focus, but we have ideas and experiences we want to share. Maybe in doing so we’re bound to be, in one way or another, always on about ourselves.

The blogosphere

I (yes, “I” again!) find this whole online world fascinating. We’re creating something genuinely new. It’s almost impossible to get a handle on how big it is, although Technorati’s 2008 report makes interesting reading (900,000 blog posts in one 24-hour period).

And who are all those bloggers? Again, Technorati give us some clues:  36% of bloggers globally are between 25 and 34 years old, 42% between 35 and 54. This is contrary to the view most people have that blogging is, as kigen puts it, “teeny-oriented”. Two-thirds are male.

I’m disappointed that fewer women write blogs, and more so that only 8% of bloggers are in my age group of 55 and up. On both counts, I wonder why.

One thing’s for sure: many bloggers are barely literate. And many blogs are poorly designed. Some start off well then either run out of steam, or lose their way. That still leaves many to choose from that are really excellent.

Egotistical?

All this doesn’t answer our main question though: is blogging inherently egotistical and should it be different?

Your views?

Image by Rick

Elsewhere:

In A Seat At The Table, Clare gives us a great example of how the world of blogging can help us think and grow.

Post to Twitter Tweet This Post

{ 20 comments… read them below or add one }

Elaine 07.02.09 at 4:10 pm

Hi Tess. I quickly checked Twitter this morning & saw your tweet about this new post. Well, I’m still working on my comment to your previous post!

So for a change I’m going to write a comment very quickly — I enjoy personal blogs, too. Yes, some may be egotistical…but I don’t read those for long. I love yours because it’s one of the excellent ones — it is honest, intelligent, challenging, well-written, well-designed, and authentic.

Blisschick 07.02.09 at 5:36 pm

Yep. Plenty of egotistical out there, but we don’t have to read it.

Furthermore, plenty of egotistical, plenty of bad writing, plenty of poor research in the PRINT world, too.

The thing about blogging is that it’s REVOLUTIONARY. It puts all the power into the hands of the writer and the reader. This is an amazing thing.

And though there are millions of blogs, the percentage of blogs that are well-written and maintained is VERY, VERY tiny. (I just saw the stats on this and can’t remember where…)

I think you can tell right away when you get to any blog whether it is a writer who happens to blog or a person who wanted to blog and so has to write.

The second group don’t last and are of no interest to me. Harsh but true. I might glance at their work but I am not at all invested.

Tess, of course, belongs to the first group. :)

kigen 07.02.09 at 6:05 pm

Tess, I Iove your blog, I was sharing
with you not speaking to the blogosphere.

Tess 07.02.09 at 6:23 pm

Elaine, Blisschick and kigen, thanks for these comments. @kigen, I’m really grateful for all your comments on the previous post, which made me think and wonder about this crazy blogging lark. @Blisschick, yes, it’s the revolutionary aspect that makes it so interesting to me, too. Completely new concept.

Eloise 07.03.09 at 5:23 am

Hi Tess,
I just found your blog and find it very interesting and thoughtful. I’m happy to tell you that I am also outside Technorati’s statistics. I am a sixty year old woman. What struck me as being very sad, is the largest age group (babyboomers) on earth, is only 8% of all bloggers. Amazing! However, blogging IS a revolutionary phenomenon with intimacy in the relationship between the reader and the writer without interference. I just started blogging May 23, 2009 and I am having fun.

Sue 07.03.09 at 1:03 pm

I’m with blisschick. Because I am a wannabe writer I often feel a bit sort of … well, as if I am being superior when I consider myself different somehow from many other bloggers. But you have hit it on the head. I’m not interested in reading the words of someone who blogs but doesn’t like to write because the words clunk, there’s little life there, its like reading technical writing.

But blogs about “me”, when written well, are eternally interesting. I think of one of my favourite authors, Helen Garner (an Aussie) whose non fiction can be about all sorts of external things (like morgues for example) and what she writes tells so much about her because she filters it all through her own perceptions. I would like to see more of that style of blogging go on. I would like to see more of it within myself :)

Thanks for bringing all this up, Kigen. I’ve been pondering it ever since :)

Tess 07.03.09 at 4:38 pm

@Eloise: welcome, and I’m glad you found my blog, thank you for your comment. I like what you said about the relationship between writer and reader, and I’m going to enjoy exploring your blog later.
@Sue: agreed – I think some people have the gift of being able to write about anything and make it interesting. It’s to do with passion for the subject, I suspect.

Barbara Anne 07.03.09 at 11:20 pm

I love the uncensored freedom of speech in the form of the written word that blogs are. As Jay Rosen said, “Blogs are little First Amendment machines.”

Long may they flourish!

Ellen 07.04.09 at 3:07 am

I too tend to enjoy blogs for the unique voice or slant they have. I have certain subjects which interest me, so I tend to stick to blogs on those subjects, but if a blog is more instructional than personal, usually I’ll lose interest. If I want instruction, I’ll usually turn to a book.

For example, I follow a fitness blog, but I don’t read it for fitness tips. I read it because the author is honest about how often he ‘falls off the fitness wagon’, how he screws up, then gets it together again. I guess I want to feel that connection, more than I want to improve myself.

Hey Tess, I’m still waiting for ‘Tess unplugged’ – the dark side… :-)

Ellen

lucy 07.04.09 at 4:05 pm

as i read this post i considered one of my previous ones about “narcissism and blogging.” as i read kigen’s quote, i thought well, that pretty much sums of my blog. i think everything in life moves (hopefully) toward the direction of self-help and thus/ultimately the help of others. now, there is a fine distinction between shoving help down someone’s throat and offering it with no strings attached…but that is where the reader has the choice to click off and move on.

i am also reminded as i just completed a memoir writing class that people are not always that interested in the person they are reading about, but how their stories or thoughts or human instincts mutually intersect. we really are most interested in “me”…and again, i would say it is a fine distinction between being a narcissist who looks in the mirror and only sees himself and the writer/blogger who puts words out there hoping to share in the reflection of the world.

one final thought…if a blog is personal…who else can we write about? i can only see things through my own lens even when i am trying to be objective and keep myself out of it.

i’ll stop before i head off into my own blog post. as always, i applaud you for making me think and thereby crystallize some of my own thoughts on topics i might not have before considered. in my humble opinion, that’s good blogging :-)

and “tess unplugged”…yea, i’d read it :-)

kigen 07.04.09 at 7:50 pm

Why defend self-centeredness, when all these blogs that are so beloved and successful are about giving one’s heart away for free?

Let the content of the blogs evolve to include diverse media, subject matter, and background or related material! Encourage the bloggers to expand parameters of what a “personal blog” can be!

Rachel 07.06.09 at 12:48 am

A much needed self check my friend. Ever so grateful for your words, and others, particularly @kigen. As ever, I find your voice so gentle, insightful, and almost always challenging in some way.

Tess 07.06.09 at 12:38 pm

Thanks for these comments, and apologies for being a bit late to respond. I’ve been moving stuff around in my studio/office and have been ‘unplugged’ in the literal sense.

I’m really enjoying the way in which you guys are taking this discussion along. Thanks again to @kigen for the prompt.

I might just add that I’m beginning to regret my threat to reveal ‘the dark side’ of Tess – I’m going to have to come up with something really special!! ;-)

Sunrise Sister 07.07.09 at 2:28 am

Well, I’m late to the reply party but I’m so glad to find it this evening and to find so many great comments. Egotistical – probably, but I find that when I’m writing – although I hope someone else will read my words – I really enjoy the act of taking words out of my mind and placing them on a page. Placing them carefully in case someone else does decide to read the words, but placing them carefully in order to understand myself. I often write posts that begin about 3 pages long and as I hack away to the essence of what’s really on my mind, I feel comforted that beneath all of those words, there is a point, and through my own personal editing, I’ve found it:)! Kigen’s words were, at first reading, harsh and made me think maybe I shouldn’t be blogging. And she would probably read this now and think I was correct. BUT her words were important to read and one of the issues that I find troubling about blogs is that we do not often speak in truth back to one another – we gloss over what we think or just don’t comment at all. WIth care and lack of sarcasm, a question opposing what I’ve written is important to receive. It makes me value the sense of sharing with others who have thoughts different than my own – it makes me feel we’re – more of us – all in this thing together……..too many words – thanks for the post and thanks for all of the wonderful comments that made me stop and think why it is I enjoy writing a blog and reading others’.

Crayons 07.07.09 at 1:01 pm

I think blogging is one of the most egotistical performative acts — even beyond theater, dance, stand-up comics, TV talk show hosts. Bogging is a perfect set-up where we can express/perform without ever having to really interact with others in real time. But egotistical isn’t always bad.

I am a nanny to a 6-year-old girl. This is the refrain all day long: “Watch me! Watch this! Look at my painting! Listen to me sing this! Look how much water I drank.” Most humans, isolated as we are, want someone to listen and praise and take us seriously.

But I pick and choose carefully. I don’t like hum-drum “we-moved-the- piano-today” blogs. I like carefully written blogs. I like blogs that turn the personal spirit-filled lens toward nature or religion or music. I also like blogs like yours that pull voices together.

Finally, and gently: as a new reader, I’m afraid that you will put my comment at the top of the next post and pull it apart. Please don’t do that.

Tess 07.07.09 at 4:15 pm

@SS: Thank you for this thoughtful response – I think for me, too, there’s an element of getting the words out of my mind partly for my own understanding. And I think you’re right in emphasising the “how” of how we repond.
@Crayons: What an interesting comparison with stand-up etc – I hadn’t thought much about the lack of real-time interaction. Although sometimes that’s almost worse – waiting for a response rather than getting it immediately I mean. And perhaps we could take lessons from the honesty of your 6-year-old charge. I’m slightly alarmed by your final paragraph! I hope kigen didn’t think I was ‘pulling her comment apart’ (are you reading this, k?). I thought it was really interesting and worth exploring. Anyway, breathe again, your words will not appear on my next post!

kigen 07.07.09 at 6:39 pm

Tess, I think the previous “not needing to be so polite” post was intoxicating! At least for me. And then from there on the next post in the comments I went for gold, and @Crayons here also — not filtering. And you responded with not filtering maybe a little? But I learned so much Tess about my need for blogs, and finally got out my reservations about them, and found a way through that, so that I am just seeing all that “heart” out there now and really not the self-involvement I had seen before, Without you i would not have understood. So I thank you Tess. Also we collaborated! Hooray! and I really enjoyed that part of it.

Tess 07.08.09 at 11:50 am

kigen: thank you, I so enjoy your comments, and also our collaboration. Hope there will be more!

Sunrise Sister 07.08.09 at 3:34 pm

Hear, hear – a terrific collaboration – thank you Tess AND Kigen!

Barney 07.11.09 at 8:01 am

Hi, Tess, I’m really late on this. I have to confess I haven’t been reading many blogs lately and I’ve been through a real blank patch with my own blog.

I’m one of those personal bloggers. I’ve nothing to sell, but I’ve feelings and experiences and ideas that need to be expressed in writing. I try not to preach – I don’t like being preached at, so why should I preach at others? But I want to share, to communicate, to interact – from the heart.

Is this valuable? Through writing and reading I reflect and learn. Self-absorbed? I hope not.

Thanks, Tess, for raising these important questions and writing your ever-stimulating blog.

Leave a Comment

You can use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>